Wednesday, 6 March 2013

Shifting alignments

Three interesting commentaries of the past couple of days have raised more questions than answers. All try to analyse shifts in political support, with no clear direction except perhaps an indication that the hallowed centre ground is shifting about like a possessed planchette beneath the feet of the parties.

First, Ambrose in the Telegraph, ostensibly on Ireland but with a verdict on EMU that should make the Eurozone an enemy of the left everywhere; "An internal devaluation is achieved (under EMU) by forcing unemployment to such excruciating levels that it breaks the back of labour resistance to pay cuts. It is the polar opposite of a currency devaluation that spreads the pain". So paradoxically the European labour movement should support the UK's devaluation of the £ that has kept unemployment low and condemn the effect of EMU on nations such as Greece, Ireland and Spain that has driven unemployment to unprecedented levels. Ambrose ends with a prediction; "Europe’s labour movement is the dog that has not barked in this long crisis. Bark it will."

Secondly, Seamus Milne in the Grauniad, ostensibly on the shift to the left of women voters in the UK but with a lesson on the effects of austerity politics on the sexes. "Crucial to the shift has been the growth of women's employment (often segregated in low-wage and public sector work), and the decline of the traditional family and churches in Europe – but also the rise of the women's movement and the influence of feminism. The importance of paid work in changing women's politics is one reason why there hasn't been a parallel shift in much of the developing world. In Britain women now make up half the trade union movement and have played a central role in recent industrial action, from the mass pensions strike of 2011 to cleaners' walkouts on the London Underground." Adding this to the observation above, it becomes clearer that within the EMU women are bearing the brunt of the economic adjustment - far more than than they are doing in the UK. Opposition to the Euro project should therefore be strongest and fastest growing amongst women voters. 

Thirdly, the Speccie's take on Beppe Grillo as a new Mussolini. "Like fascism, Grillo’s movement is essentially left-wing and in favour of the state sorting things out — the Italian state. But it is against the euro and Europe — and Germany in particular" writes Nicholas Farrell. Other commentaries - particularly de Spiegel - dismiss as simplistic the classification of the Grillini as left wing. They're rather on the other axis of the scale. libertarianism vs authoritarianism. And they're young.

If Cameron characterises the typical opponents of the Euro project as middle aged men in polyester blazers he ignores an emerging powerful constituency of educated young women who are facing more than men insecure and poorly rewarded employment, non-existent pensions, the setting back of a century of women's struggle for independence and who are fed up with Cameron's sleek lounge-lizard clique of privileged wealthy metropolitan men. If Farage is not to disappear in the 2015 election, he needs their votes.


G. Tingey said...

Yes ... libertarian, & quite possible left libertarian (Think Kropotkin as an extreme example)
This is wher Camoron has got it so badly out of cintact he isn't even wrong in a famous phrase....

If you want a really radical take on it, there's the Irish equivalent of the TUC saying that the EU make the horrible imperialist Brits look like nice people to know [ I told you so, remember! ]
See here ....

Excuse me while I go off & have a larff ....
Long live the federated Union of the Isles!
( & stuff the EU )

right_writes said...

Although Nigel is portrayed as a bit of a bombast by the media, he is a very affable chap in person and good company, which appeals to both men and women.

But his real advantage is that, even though he is getting pretty good at superficial interviews, which he deals with like a smart politician...

...He isn't a proper politician, he is the bloke next door and he is relatively normal by political standards.

How refreshing!

Anonymous said...

I think Nigel Farage is fully aware of that.
Hence this young lady here.

Anonymous said...

Its the agenda, stupid (to incorrectly coin a phrase). You see, none of the centralist 3 parties are even prepared to accept that the public's agenda is their agenda. We want - Out of the EU. Out of Afghanistan. Out of recession. the corporatists grow richer and the rest grow poorer. This just cannot go on much longer.

Coney Island

DeeDee99 said...

I fit the profile you have described of female, reasonably well-educated and working in the public sector.

I've been a UKIP member for several years now.

I thoroughly dislike the patrician style of Cameron and the patronising pandering to "wimmins issues" which LibLabCON endorse.

Farage may be a "hail fellow, well met" type - but he isn't chauvinistic. He's a breath of fresh air.