Cookie Notice

This site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services and analyze traffic. Your IP address and user-agent are shared with Google along with performance and security metrics to ensure quality of service, generate usage statistics, and to detect and address abuse.

Friday, 25 August 2017

Judicial competence

This is a post in praise of the EU. Or maybe to the UK's influence in having introduced to sclerotic and protectionist Europe just a little of the many advantages in terms of access to justice that we enjoy in the UK.

Austria, like much of Europe, has no commercial law small claims procedure. To resolve an intractable contract dispute here, even a small one, means each side lawyering-up at €300/hr for even the most mediocre and least competent of lawyers and a full court hearing before career commercial judges. Contrast with the UK, in which claims for up to £10,000 (£1,000 for personal injury and landlord/tenant) are dealt with under the small claims track of civil procedure, often called small claims courts or county courts, in which an experienced local solicitor often sits as Recorder. Legal costs are not claimable, and court fees are fixed in advance. 

Well, the EU has introduced a cross-Europe small claims track, and you can sense the dragging of the vast protectionist hulk of Euronational self-interest in opposition to it. For a start, the limit is €5,000. And it only applies to disputes with persons or firms in other EU countries. Otherwise, it's remarkably like our own small claims procedure. It's invaluable to anyone doing business with Germans, who have still to discover how customer relations works. I buy a lot of building material online from German firms - they tend to be 30% cheaper than local Austrian outlets for the same materials - and of course from time to time there are problems. 

I ordered two WCs for the en-suites from a German firm. One was broken in transit and they went back to the firm without reaching me. A UK firm would have said "Tut mir leid Herr Raedwald we've broken one of your WCs. We can't get another for three weeks. So if it's OK we'll send you the good one now and the other when they come into stock. And we'll give you a £50 online voucher by way of apology". 

The German way? "One of your WCs has been broken and we can't replace it until September. If you want the other one now, that will be an additional €90 carriage." Well, I wasn't happy. The emails went back and forth until the Germans smugly responded "And what are you going to do about it?" whereupon I sent them my draft of the EU claim form, requesting also that the case be heard near to me in Austria, by an Austrian court, this option being available for consumers when dealing with foreign firms. 

The result? No online voucher - they haven't learnt that much - but a surly confirmation that my intact WC was on its way. Free of additional charge.   

7 comments:

DeeDee99 said...

Meanwhile, our real friends, the Americans would have offered you higher-quality WCs as replacements; couriered them to you that day; given you a voucher for future discount AND would have requested that you "Have a nice day."

John Miller said...

To Germans, everybody else looks like a little girl in Rotterdam circa 1940.

joe winner said...

Fascinating insight into German society, thank you

English Pensioner said...

This is why my daughter's US employer made it clear to staff that they had no intention of moving their European Headquarters away from England as a result of Brexit as they wished to continue to operate under UK commercial law.

Anonymous said...

Some insights into the Germanic world come from a small volume produced by Smith's Industries KLG Spark Plugs division on their move from Putney. KLG had provided spark plugs to Mercedes' winning car in a race before WW1, and the invoice was not honoured because of the war. In 1939, some machine tools ordered from Bosch were actually delivered after the outbreak of WW2, via Sweden. Which makes me think that there are (at least) two sides to the Germanic character.

John Brown said...

I worked in textiles for many years with suppliers from France, Germany, Italy and China.

Only the Germans were caught cheating on the fibre composition so in a way I was not surprised to learn about the German diesel emissions scandal discovered by the USA.

The US car owners have been/are being compensated.

But are any EU owners being compensated ?

Have the EU fined either the EU testing house which gave EU wide approval or the German car manufacturers ?

One of the numerous reasons that the EU is so upset by the UK leaving is that we will be outside of their control and consequently/hopefully more likely to detect such cheating and obtain compensation for our citizens.

Anonymous said...

Wow. As you say Germans know nothing about customer service. So it comes as no surprise the EU(Germany) negotiations are so difficult due for the most part to their intractability and obstruction. Is it their arrogance that they can never own up to being less than perfect all the time that they must always hold the upper hand even when they have nothing to back it up?